| Rank | Name | Time/Score | Start | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Max Hunger '20 | SCH 4:27.72 | F | 2020 |
| 2 | Sam Donchi '20 | AA 4:30.60 | F | 2019 |
| 3 | Jun Oh '12 | SCHAA 4:30.74 | F | 2012 |
| 4 | Anthony Minickiello '20 | 4:36.22 | F | 2020 |
| 5 | Conor McAuliffe '10 | 4:39.22 | F | 2010 |
| 6 | Adam Vlasic '20 | 4:41.14 | F | 2018 |
| 7 | Jon Bernstein '86 | SCH 4:42.48 | F | 1985 |
| 8 | Travis Bouscaren '14 | 4:44.08 | F | 2013 |
| 9 | Noah Caruso '92 | 4:44.47 | F | 1992 |
| 10 | Riku Tanaka '20 | 4:46.28 | F | 2020 |
| 11 | Brian Fiske '03 | 4:47.36 | F | 2000 |
| 12 | Marcello Rossi '16 | 4:47.64 | F | 2014 |
| 13 | Matt Mahoney '11 | 4:47.79 | F | 2008 |
| 14 | Hank Yang '22 | 4:48.28 | F | 2020 |
| 15 | Derek Neathery '97 | 4:49.35 | F | 1997 |
| 16 | Connor Fraser '13 | 4:49.87 | F | 2013 |
| 17 | Brian Croll '79 | 4:50.40 | F | 1979 |
| 18 | Caleb Hellerman '88 | 4:50.40 | F | 1988 |
| 19 | Robert Leroy '88 | 4:51.83 | F | 1987 |
| 20 | Tim Wynter '14 | 4:52.57 | F | 2013 |
| 21 | Lance Freiman '19 | 4:53.04 | F | 2018 |
| 22 | David Mainen '89 | 4:53.47 | F | 1989 |
| 23 | Aaron Teo '15 | 4:53.66 | F | 2014 |
| 24 | Nick Isenhower '18 | 4:53.69 | F | 2018 |
| 25 | Doug Friman '93 | 4:54.30 | F | 1993 |