| Rank | Name | Time/Score | Start | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Myles Standish '73 | AA 3:51.00 | F | 1973 |
| 2 | John Kingery '75 | 3:54.90 | F | 1973 |
| 3 | Peter Anderson '72 | 3:59.80 | F | 1971 |
| 4 | Tim Neville '71 | 4:09.90 | F | 1969 |
| 5 | Michael Murphy '74 | 4:10.60 | F | 1973 |
| 6 | Nate Cartmell '69 | 4:15.00 | F | 1968 |
| 7 | John Phillips '65 | SCH 4:19.10 | F | 1964 |
| 8 | William Bostian '67 | 4:21.30 | F | 1966 |
| 9 | J. Thomas '65 | 4:23.50 | F | 1965 |
| 10 | Albert Raurell '66 | 4:25.70 | F | 1965 |